Amazon.com Widgets

As featured on p. 218 of "Bloggers on the Bus," under the name "a MyDD blogger."

Friday, December 15, 2006

CA Lethal Injection Method Ruled Unconstitutional

In district court today, Judge Jeremy Fogel, who earlier imposed a moratorium on all executions in the state, ruled that the current method of imposing the death penalty via lethal injection risks violating the Constitutional ban on cruel and unusual punishment.  The judge did say that "California's implementation of lethal injection is broken, but it can be fixed."

This is the second state in recent months to rule this particular type of lethal injection unconstitutional, joining Missouri. In addition, this comes on the heels of a report that death penalty cases are at their lowest number in decades, 60% below its peak in 1999.

I'm wondering exactly how the situation could be fixed to minimize the amount of pain and suffering.  The issue, as I remember, is that the anaesthetic administered was not sufficient to definitively eliminate pain.

This is yet another capper on the troubled legal system in the state, including the prison overcrowding problem, where the judiciary has stepped in and demanded a fix within six months or prisoners must be released.

More as it develops.

UPDATE: I don't think it was related, but Florida suspended all of their executions today after it was revealed through an autopsy that their last execution victim suffered from a botched series of injections. One of the things I remember from the great movie Mr. Death was that Fred Leuchter, the protagonist, was a guy who designed electric chairs, and when the states largely switched over to lethal injection machines, they had Leuchter design them because they figured "well, you design electric chairs, you can do it." There is no care taken in the design of these machines, and until now nobody really speaking for the death row inmates and the violation of their Constitutional rights. Clearly the technology is there to satisfy such concerns, but the states don't give a crap.

Of course, to believe that you can execute death sentences humanely, you have to believe that state-sponsored execution is not in and of itself cruel and unusual punishment.

|