Amazon.com Widgets

As featured on p. 218 of "Bloggers on the Bus," under the name "a MyDD blogger."

Tuesday, April 21, 2009

Richie Riches In The Blogosphere

I think just about every blogger has taken a hack at this today, but Mark Penn has no idea what he's talking about. The income I make on this blog, and I would assume I'm in the vast majority, pays for one dinner, in a good week. Maybe there are a hundred or so in the liberal blogosphere making a living. Penn's numbers are simply wrong.

Now, gentle readers, you can prove me wrong by donating to my blograiser. But you could be quite sure that I wouldn't be spending time blograising if the ad sales was doing the job. I think the ad to your right is the only one I've had all year. Blogads has fallen off the cliff, especially out here in the long tail. If there are 452,000 people blogging as their primary source of income, that basically equals 452,000 unemployed people.

Lane Hudson takes this a bit further. The world where there are a half a million working bloggers must be the same world where Hillary Clinton has locked up the Democratic nomination because all the states are winner-take-all.

That said, I think it's a noble goal. I'd certainly welcome a world with a bunch of paid bloggers. In fact, the only way to do that now is with low-dollar community donations. Firedoglake has a funding drive up to support Marcy Wheeler in her investigative reporting. I've found Marcy's work invaluable and well worth supporting, so I recommend the effort. Not to mention my own, of course... :)

Labels: , , ,

|

Monday, August 11, 2008

The Penn's Ink

Josh Green's mammoth piece about the fall of the Clinton campaign is up, as well as this stock of memos that reveal a chaotic, backbiting, and downright angry group of advisers. Chief strategist Mark Penn's strategy to target Barack Obama's lack of American roots is obviously the bombshell here.

I don't think it's that crucial to talk about this; campaigns falter for all sorts of reasons, and this case appears to be a factor of a little over-confidence, a little internal conflict between powerful forces and a whole lot of not knowing the rules of the game they were playing (Harold Ickes Cassandra-like cries about delegate counts have a wistful quality to them, like the movie you watch where you know all the characters should be listening to one guy's warnings but they never do). What I do think is crucial is to formally and totally discredit Mark Penn, who spent the entire campaign dominating internal rivals, producing magic polling to cement his own preconceptions, pushing bullshit narratives like the "Obama isn't American" nonsense, and generally shitting on everyone inside or outside the campaign. The man should never approach a Democratic campaign as long as he lives.

I could care less about why this was leaked this week or who fought with who inside the campaign or whatever; it's all catnip for the traditional media but meaningless to me. What stays with you is Penn, in all his shabby glory. He's a pathetic figure, and I hope that remains his legacy.

Labels: , , ,

|

Wednesday, July 09, 2008

Why Clinton Was So Bitterly Opposed

As many people (including me) said during the primary, it wasn't so much about the candidate as the people around her who she chose to run her campaign, which of course reflects on her judgment and how she would run her White House. When you see Howard Wolfson bolt to Fox News after the primary, and justify it by saying how fair and balanced they were during the primary (he's worked for Rupert Murdoch before, by the way, as a lobbyist); when you see Mark Penn signing up Karen Hughes to work at his public relations firm; you get the sense that these people aren't all that committed to progressive values, and as much as the candidate determines policy, having guys like Wolfson and Penn on the front lines of another White House makes me cringe.

I don't know that Obama is completely better, but I do know that he ran a better campaign with far less drama and employees that didn't decide to become personalities. And when you see all the turmoil in the McCain campaign, where nobody will admit who's actually in charge, and the clash of egos at the top, you get the sense that his years in a potential White House would be a clusterfuck. So too with Clinton. In this sense, how you campaign and how you organize your executive branch are linked - of the three, Obama is clearly the much better manager, despite the perceived lack of experience in such a capacity.

Labels: , , , , , , ,

|

Thursday, May 08, 2008

If We Were Still Operating Under the 3/5 Compromise, I'd Be The Nominee

I can't do much better than what dnA did to this Hillary Clinton comment:

"I have a much broader base to build a winning coalition on," she said in an interview with USA TODAY. As evidence, Clinton cited an Associated Press article "that found how Sen. Obama's support among working, hard-working Americans, white Americans, is weakening again, and how whites in both states who had not completed college were supporting me."

"There's a pattern emerging here," she said.


Not only is that completely insulting, the emerging pattern for decades in the Democratic Party, so obvious that even George Bush picked up on it in 2004, is how many take the black vote totally for granted. That's exactly the bias Clinton is betraying here. She may think that blacks are real people and hard-working Americans, but she doesn't think of them enough to think they matter in electoral politics because they'll all go Democratic anyway. dnA notes how Hillary's husband didn't set the world on fire among whites, either:

This kind of comment is less a description than an agitator, it's meant to give white voters the impression that they would be "disenfranchised" by an Obama win. It's a not so subtle effort to evoke racial resentment over Obama's success.

But the truth is, Clinton won't win the white vote either, as Steve M. points out:

According to CNN's 1996 exit poll, Bill Clinton lost the white vote (Dole 46%, Clinton 43%, Perot 9%). He lost the white male vote by an even larger margin (Dole 49%, Clinton 38%, Perot 11%). And he lost gun owners badly (Dole 51%, Clinton 38%, Perot 10%). However, Clinton won the popular vote overall

In 2000 -- when Al Gore won the popular vote by half a million votes -- he lost white males to Bush by a whopping 60%-36%, according to CNN's exit poll. He lost men overall 53%-42%. He lost whites overall 54%-42%. He lost gun owners 61%-36%. He lost small-town voters 59%-38% and rural voters 59%-37%. He lost the Midwest overall 49%-48%.

I'm not saying these are goals to aspire to. I'm saying it's a myth that Democrats had Joe Sixpack in their back pockets until that snooty arugula-eater Barack Obama came along, and it's a myth that they suffer crushing defeats when bowlers and boilermaker-drinkers aren't on board. 49%-41%-8%, and he won 70% of the electoral votes.

But it's a myth that Clinton needs to perpetuate to make a case for her continued candidacy.


It also shows how she'd run a general election: shootin' guns, drinkin' shots, saying whatever 8 yahoos in Ohio believe is the key and taking the black vote that would put her over the top for granted, even though she's insulted them here. I don't subscribe to the idea that Clinton has run a "race-baiting" campaign, and this isn't entirely a "race-baiting" comment, it's a "taking blacks for granted" comment. Which to me is worse.

Fortunately, we don't actually have to worry a lot about this. House members are turning their backs on Clinton, the money is drying up, her insiders are wavering, and it's basically over without fully being over. I agree that she ought to stay in for another two weeks so that the perception is not that Obama becomes the nominee and promptly gets thrashed in West Virginia and Kentucky, his two worst states in the nation. As long as the kitchen sink strategy ends immediately, she can go ahead and "press on" as long as she wants. But it won't end in the nomination.

And that result is mostly because Obama is a great candidate who ran a superior campaign. But the inferiority of the Clinton campaign, given the institutional advantages she had, cannot be dismissed. This reads like a joke:

Clinton picked people for her team primarily for their loyalty to her, instead of their mastery of the game. That became abundantly clear in a strategy session last year, according to two people who were there. As aides looked over the campaign calendar, chief strategist Mark Penn confidently predicted that an early win in California would put her over the top because she would pick up all the state's 370 delegates. It sounded smart, but as every high school civics student now knows, Penn was wrong: Democrats, unlike the Republicans, apportion their delegates according to vote totals, rather than allowing any state to award them winner-take-all. Sitting nearby, veteran Democratic insider Harold M. Ickes, who had helped write those rules, was horrified — and let Penn know it. "How can it possibly be," Ickes asked, "that the much vaunted chief strategist doesn't understand proportional allocation?" And yet the strategy remained the same, with the campaign making its bet on big-state victories. Even now, it can seem as if they don't get it. Both Bill and Hillary have noted plaintively that if Democrats had the same winner-take-all rules as Republicans, she'd be the nominee.


In fairness to her, if it weren't for black people, Democrats would have changed proportional allocation to winner-take-all. Right?

Labels: , , , , , , ,

|

Tuesday, April 08, 2008

Penn Still Full Of Ink, Actually

So it looks like rumors of the demise of Mark Penn were greatly exaggerated. He's still sitting in on conference calls, he's still delivering poliing and message, and he's still part of the inner circle in the Clinton campaign. Even campaign spokepersons are acknowledging that he is playing an important role.

Which is fine, of course. But this also means that Penn's actions remain fair game for the rival campaign. He's either an advisor or he isn't, and these events clearly indicate that he is. And so the incident with the Colombian government on the pending free trade agreement, on which George Bush has forced a vote in the Congress, will continue to be a significant part of the debate. This seems like a bad strategy for the Clinton campaign; a clean break would have short-circuited the controversy.

Labels: , , , ,

|

Sunday, April 06, 2008

Penn Runs Out Of Ink - Or Does It?

I'm pretty confused about this way-too-late firing of Clinton strategist Mark Penn, mainly because it does not appear to be a firing at all, since Penn will be providing the same strategic advice that he has all along.

After the events of the last few days, Mark Penn has asked to give up his role as Chief Strategist of the Clinton Campaign; Mark, and Penn, Schoen and Berland Associates, Inc. will continue to provide polling and advice to the campaign.

Geoff Garin and Howard Wolfson will coordinate the campaign's strategic message team going forward.


If the pollster is still providing polling, and the strategist is still providing advice, has anything changed but the title?

Labels: , ,

|

Friday, April 04, 2008

Populist Advisor

This revelation that Mark Penn is advising on the Colombian free trade deal while his candidate is out there bashing NAFTA at every opportunity really rankles. Clinton's continued loyalty to Penn reflects horribly on her, and certainly won't help her in the trustworthiness department. Of course, I don't think Obama is committed to dismantling NAFTA either - if we want that to happen we have to demand it.

Labels: , , , , ,

|

Wednesday, March 05, 2008

Democrats In Disarray

Now that the press beat up on Barack Obama for a few days it's Hillary Clinton's turn. The WaPo runs an inside baseball piece about internal hatred among her staff, which is not really germane for A1, but certainly germane to push the narrative that this extended race is dooming the Democrats.

For the bruised and bitter staff around Sen. Hillary Rodham Clinton, Tuesday's death-defying victories in the Democratic presidential primaries in Ohio and Texas proved sweet indeed. They savored their wins yesterday, plotted their next steps and indulged in a moment of optimism. "She won't be stopped," one aide crowed.

And then Clinton's advisers turned to their other goal: denying Mark Penn credit.

With a flurry of phone calls and e-mail messages that began before polls closed, campaign officials made clear to friends, colleagues and reporters that they did not view the wins as validation for the candidate's chief strategist. "A lot of people would still like to see him go," a senior adviser said.

The depth of hostility toward Penn even in a time of triumph illustrates the combustible environment within the Clinton campaign, an operation where internal strife and warring camps have undercut a candidate once seemingly destined for the Democratic nomination. Clinton now faces the challenge of exploiting this moment of opportunity while at the same time deciding whether the squabbling at her Arlington headquarters has become a distraction that requires her intervention.


I dislike Mark Penn as much as the next Clinton staffer, and certainly she has not had the campaign people she deserves in this race, but why does this matter to anyone but the most hardcore junkie?

The media has also unilaterally decided for us that negative ads won the race (I think it had something to do with it, but so did demographics and the fact that Obama's voter contact and organizing strategy diminishes somewhat in very large states), and that the problem was that Obama didn't "fight back" even though he put out a competing "3 AM, you should be afraid for a different reason" ad within a matter of hours, and sure enough, the next day a story with the headline Lesson of Defeat: Obama Comes Out Punching can be written. So they get the knock-down drag-out fight they demand, pushing FURTHER the story that Democrats are fighting, Clinton supporters hate Obama supporters, Obama supporters hate Clinton supporters, and nobody will show up to the polls in November. Note the beginning of the NY Times story:

Senator Barack Obama woke up on Wednesday talking of his delegate lead and of taking the fight to Senator Hillary Rodham Clinton. But after defeats in two of the most populous states, he also sounded like a chastened candidate in search of his lost moment.


So here we have a story where Obama is winning but really losing, matched by a story where Clinton is winning but really losing. Message: Democrats are losers. The whole extended campaign is colored with this theme: it's not Democrats have two talented and resilient candidates, it's that the party is weak and about to explode. Never mind the facts.

Then there's the NAFTA/Canada boomerang, with a Canadian story suggesting that Clinton's team also gave assurances to their neighbors to the north that the strident rhetoric on the trade deal was mostly talk. Apparently phone lines from the nation's largest newspapers don't reach all the way to Ottawa, because this story which could have been cleared up in 20 minutes played out over the course of a week, damaging Obama and now potentially damaging Clinton. It's also contextless, since media types don't know a goddamn thing about trade policy and don't understand the difference between cancellation and renegotiation. If they did, they'd have understood that both candidates' position on trade was actually logically consistent with what they told Canadian officials and WOULD HAVE NEVER REPORTED THE STORY.

Expect bullshit like this for the next seven weeks. And read critically.

Labels: , , , , , , ,

|

Wednesday, February 27, 2008

California Mattered - It Lost The Election For Clinton

In an incredible article in the New York Observer, former White House Chief of Staff Leon Panetta rips apart Hillary Clinton's campaign staff for being unready for a national race for the Presidency and dismissive of Barack Obama's strengths. He had strong words for Mark Penn (he "comes from an old school, like Karl Rove—it’s all about dividing people into smaller groups rather than taking the broader approach that was needed.”), considered campaign manager Patti Solis Doyle too inexperienced, and added this very insightful bit:

Aside from his criticisms of specific people at the top of Mrs. Clinton’s team, he also asserted that the campaign in general had neither created an efficient ground operation nor shown tactical wisdom in its deployment of available resources.

“It seems to me like they rolled the dice on Super Tuesday, thinking that would end it,” he said. “And when it didn’t end it, they didn’t have a plan. And when it came to the caucus states, they did have a plan—which was to ignore them. I think those were serious mistakes.”


This seems right to me. The bulk of the ground operation was put not only into Super Tuesday states, but in particular the large Super Tuesday states, in addition to the early states, of course. Clinton's team bought completely into a momentum-based strategy: she would sweep the early states, get a victory in the media based on winning the big electoral prizes on Super Tuesday, and muscle everyone else out of the race. There were obvious advantages, like having practically the whole Northeast voting on February 5, where she had ties as a Senator. But the strategy simply wouldn't have worked without California as the big prize. So she locked up the entire political establishment early, recognizing that this state is simply too big to run an efficient ground operation without that establishment help.

When she lost Iowa and South Carolina, it became obvious that Clinton would not be able to finish Obama off on Super Tuesday. Obvious to everyone, that is, except for Clinton's campaign. So while Obama actually took out ads in post-Super Tuesday states back in late January, Clinton literally had no campaign apparatus anywhere beyond February 5. She was far from "ready on day one," but completely unready for a protracted challenge. Which is why California actually did have an impact on the nomination - it lulled Clinton into a false sense of security.

It's one thing for pundits to believe the rhetoric that California is the "ultimate showdown"; it's quite another for the candidate to believe the same thing. And the signs were all there well before Californians went to the polls. Hillary Clinton deserves to sue her campaign for political malpractice - but she also may have a case against those legislators who moved California early in the process, creating a mirage of a "winner-take-all" situation. A spread-out process without a one-day blitz would have obviously served her much better, simply because she wouldn't have been able to put all of her eggs in one basket. In truth, she shouldn't have anyway.

Labels: , , , ,

|

Friday, February 22, 2008

What $3.8 Million Buys You

Really bad spin and messaging.

The firm that includes Mark Penn, Mrs. Clinton’s chief strategist and pollster, and his team collected $3.8 million for fees and expenses in January; in total, including what the campaign still owes, the firm has billed more than $10 million for consulting, direct mail and other services, an amount other Democratic strategists who are not affiliated with either campaign called stunning.


I would never give Hillary Clinton a dime just knowing that Mark Penn would take a decent amount of it for himself. As The Editors say, "What an amazing gig this guy has. Never won anything, terrible at his job, gets paid truly exorbitant amounts of money for the privilege. He should be appointed head of FEMA."

I don't even know what he's doing for that money. Is he being paid for forgetting that there might still be an election going on beyond Super Tuesday? For getting smoked in GOTV? For relying on big donors so much that the campaign has to hastily assemble an illegal 527 just to keep financial parity? For the messaging of insulting Democrats in every state that won't vote for his candidate? I mean, Hillary's trying to downplay Texas now.

There’s been a lot of talk about what your campaign would do should it get to the convention. Would you commit today to honoring the agreement made earlier not to seat the Michigan and Florida delegations?

Let’s talk about the agreement. The only agreement I entered into was not to campaign in Michigan and Florida. It had nothing to do with not seating the delegates. I think that’s an important distinction. I did not campaign-- [...]

The press seems to have missed the distinction if that’s the case. The talk is that you agreed not to seat the delegation.

That’s not the case at all. I signed an agreement not to campaign in Michigan and Florida. Now, the DNC made the determination that they would not seat the delegates, but I was not party to that. I think it’s important for the DNC to ask itself, Is this really in the best interest of our eventual nominee? We do not want to be disenfranchising Michigan and Florida. We have to try to carry both of those states. I’d love to carry Texas, but it’s usually not in the electoral calculation for the Democratic nominee. Florida and Michigan are.


You can't just trash Texas Democrats and run a 5-state strategy if you want a working majority. 50% plus one doesn't cut it. Mark Penn doesn't get this. He does, however, get $3,8 million dollars in a month, which means that I'm in the wrong line of work.

Labels: , , , , ,

|

Saturday, February 16, 2008

Give That Man A Muzzle

Has anybody spoken more gibberish during a Presidential campaign in just a week than Mark Penn? Days after the "Barack Obama hasn't won any significant states" nonsense, he rolls out this gem:

"Winning Democratic primaries is not a qualification or a sign of who can win the general election. If it were, every nominee would win because every nominee wins Democratic primaries.”


Why didn't we think of that before? This primary business is so outdated. Sometimes the winner of the primaries doesn't win the election! There has to be a better way. Hmm... we could just leave it up to whoever Mark Penn decides should be the nominee? Run that one by him, I think he'll get on board.

Between that stuff and the new Clinton message (and all messaging goes through Mark Penn) that Obama can't be a substantive guy because his speeches are too good, it's been a hell of a week for easily mocked quotes.

(by the way, if you want to look at beyond speeches, and at the two candidates' actual records, Hilzoy did the legwork.)

Labels: , , , ,

|

Friday, February 15, 2008

All My Candidates Are In Texas

Three polls out from Texas today with wildly different results, which is right in line with the wide variance in polling this year. Rasmussen has Clinton up by 19 and ARG has Obama up by 6. ARG has been terrible this election cycle.

The one that interests me, however, is this one commissioned by the Texas Credit Union League. It has Clinton up 49-41, which sounds about right (maybe a little low), but it reiterates that Obama has some natural, built-in advantages with the delegate count:

Even though Clinton leads by 8 points in polling statewide, based upon the following sub-samples, Obama would still come out with a delegate lead.

And that's just among delegates allocated by the primary, not our additional caucus process which Obama has proven deft at winning delegates through.

I'm not kidding, follow me below...

"Clinton also enjoys majority support in the South (57%) and Western (61%) regions of the state, and edges ahead in the Eastern part of the state 46% to 40%. Obama is beating Clinton 53% to 32% in the Central region and leads 49% to 44% in the Houston area. The Dallas Fort-Worth region is tied within margin of error (Clinton 42%, Obama 41%)."


Which means that Clinton actually needs something like a blowout to get the delegate split she needs in Texas. All of which is to say that Mark Penn is an idiot when he claims that "Texas, Ohio and Pennsylvania ... have 492 delegates - 64 percent of the remaining delegates Hillary Clinton needs to win the nomination," because she's not going to win those states by a 100-0 count.

In a somewhat related note, Markos agrees with me that the whole superdelegate thing is way overblown. The nominee is going to win this on the ground and at the polls, and either of them can right now. I also agree with this:

What's most interesting to me about this whole affair, however, is that the Clintonistas would even suggest the use of super delegates to subvert the will of the Democratic Party electorate. It betrays a lack of confidence in their candidate's electoral viability, even with a calendar that will become far more favorable to her in March, while seemingly confirming every right-wing charge that the Clintons place winning above all else, including principle.

That they would even suggest a tactic that would sunder the Democratic Party, kicking off a vicious and destructive civil war, tells me that like Bill in the 90s, when our majorities in Congress and all around the country were decimated and the party's base left to wither and die, Hillary will put her own interests above those of their party. And to me, there's no greater sin in Democratic politics than that.

So the Clinton campaign has graduated from saying that certain states don't matter, to saying certain voters don't matter, to now saying that the Democratic Party electorate doesn't matter.

Labels: , , , , , ,

|

Thursday, February 14, 2008

Your Candidate Sucks.

Really? Did Hillary Clinton actually try to attack Barack Obama for cozying up to the nuclear industry in the Exelon case, when her chief strategist Mark Penn just took $230,000 from said company? Did that actually happen?

And is the Obama campaign, as well as supporters like MoveOn, really talking about the need for superdelegates to respect the "will of the people" when clearly they're talking about respecting the will of getting Obama into office?

And are both sides giving hundreds of thousands of dollars to these same superdelegates, and somehow do people find it exceptional that politicians help other politicians with campaign cash?

(By the way, most superdelegates win state-based DNC races and don't get a smidge, even a little bit, of campaign cash. They're party activists who represent state-based activists, and they're the ones who elected Howard Dean to the chairmanship against the will of the establishment. Anyone who thinks superdelegates are going to in any way decide the nominee at the convention is out of their fucking mind. There is no way they will rip four years' worth of party building asunder and actively participate in their own destruction. The winner of this nomination will be the winner of the votes in the primaries, period. Anything else is idle speculation, and the media gooses it to actively set the Party against itself. Thanks a lot for buying into it, online community!)

My initial decision to back John Edwards (and to an extent, Chris Dodd) looks better with each passing day. They're flawed, though, too. EVERYONE in politics is flawed. The only candidate that's going to fit your perfect model is, well, you. Otherwise, you're going to have to settle for an imperfect human being. And if you don't like it, do something about it. The man in the arena and all that.

It is not the critic who counts; not the man who points out how the strong man stumbles, or where the doer of deeds could have done them better. The credit belongs to the man who is actually in the arena, whose face is marred by dust and sweat and blood; who strives valiantly; who errs, who comes short again and again, because there is no effort without error and shortcoming; but who does actually strive to do the deeds; who knows great enthusiasms, the great devotions; who spends himself in a worthy cause; who at the best knows in the end the triumph of high achievement, and who at the worst, if he fails, at least fails while daring greatly, so that his place shall never be with those cold and timid souls who neither know victory nor defeat. Shame on the man of cultivated taste who permits refinement to develop into fastidiousness that unfits him for doing the rough work of a workaday world. Among the free peoples who govern themselves there is but a small field of usefulness open for the men of cloistered life who shrink from contact with their fellows. Still less room is there for those who deride of slight what is done by those who actually bear the brunt of the day; nor yet for those others who always profess that they would like to take action, if only the conditions of life were not exactly what they actually are. The man who does nothing cuts the same sordid figure in the pages of history, whether he be a cynic, or fop, or voluptuary. There is little use for the being whose tepid soul knows nothing of great and generous emotion, of the high pride, the stern belief, the lofty enthusiasm, of the men who quell the storm and ride the thunder. Well for these men if they succeed; well also, though not so well, if they fail, given only that they have nobly ventured, and have put forth all their heart and strength. It is war-worn Hotspur, spent with hard fighting, he of the many errors and valiant end, over whose memory we love to linger, not over the memory of the young lord who "but for the vile guns would have been a valiant soldier."


As I've been saying for weeks now, the candidate itself ultimately doesn't matter as much as the progressive movement's ability to be engaged in the process. The engagement and participation on FISA has yielded better results thus far than anyone thought possible. Yes, FISA itself is a step back from the Constitutional provisions of the Fourth Amendment. But the Constitution doesn't really apply to noncitizens - that'd be the "foreign" part of the Foreign Intelligence Surveillance Act. And so the FISA provisions, put in place under President Carter, responsibly strike the balance between intelligence gathering and civil liberties protections. And they were utterly trashed by a rogue President and a pliant Congress, and regular people fought back, and did more to stop what is actually an establishment wave toward giving up liberties and sanctioning lawbreaking than I ever thought possible.

All of this nonsense about character flaws and which candidate has the most earmarks (right, because the defense budget isn't one giant frackin' earmark that John McCain mainlines personally to his defense buddies in Arizona) and who's playing what identity card is really exhausting. This is about policy, but when the policies are similar, it's about who is going to invite a people-powered coalition to help in the prospect of changing the country from the bottom up. The individual flawed politician who excites and inspires that coalition is kind of immaterial. And those who are so desperate to score a point or two so they can cheer and high-five to the other 100 or so online friends in their corner are engaging in behavior I rolled my eyes at in junior high school. It bears no resemblance to the real world, where these particular flawed politicians are actually broadly popular. But it sure gives the Republican oppo research shops a lot to work with. Thanks, blogosphere!

UPDATE: And thanks, campaign surrogates! Joe Wilson's recycling a smear from right-wing blogs, almost verbatim, to attack Obama. Good work!

(apologies to Thers for ripping off the title)

Labels: , , , , , , , ,

|

It's Not War When One Side Doesn't Need To Fight

The Clinton campaign is fighting a battle in the media to ensure that the "Obama is winning" narrative doesn't take hold. That's what this is all about. The numbers pretty clearly show that it's likely Obama will be ahead in pledged delegates by the end of the nominating process. So the Clintons are resorting to spin - and bad spin, at that.

Strategists said in a conference call with reporters the campaign will go after delegates wherever they can be found -- including in Michigan and Florida. They also said Clinton will likely be within 25 delegates of Obama after voting on March 4, including superdelegates, and they dismissed most states which Obama has won.

“Could we possibly have a nominee who hasn't won any of the significant states -- outside of Illinois?” Chief Strategist Mark Penn said. “That raises some serious questions about Sen. Obama.”


There is something to be said for the adage that you govern the way you campaign. The Clinton campaign is dedicated to an 18-state strategy where you need a triple-bank shot to get lucky on election day, and she'll probably govern that way, too, foregrounding the big states as necessarily more important and doing little to promote Democrats outside of them. The Obama campaign is running hard everywhere, and are most likely to continue Howard Dean's 50-state strategy. I don't think they would ever call a state, or its citizens, "insignificant."

Then there's this article, which suggests that the Clinton camp knows that they'll be down in pledged delegates but will try to win with superdelegates.

WASHINGTON -- Hillary Clinton will take the Democratic nomination even if she does not win the popular vote, but persuades enough superdelegates to vote for her at the convention, her campaign advisers say.

The New York senator, who lost three primaries Tuesday night, now lags slightly behind her rival, Illinois Senator Barack Obama, in the delegate count. She is even further behind in "pledged'' delegates, those assigned by virtue of primaries and caucuses.

But Clinton will not concede the race to Obama if he wins a greater number of pledged delegates by the end of the primary season, and will count on the 796 elected officials and party bigwigs to put her over the top, if necessary, said Clinton's communications director, Howard Wolfson.


This is a public plea for the superdelegates already in her camp to stay with her, nothing more. As I've said, it is highly unlikely that Democratic activists (and that's who a lot of the superdelegates are) would subvert the will of the people. That's actually not how they operate and not who they are. The 400 or so who haven't endorsed are a bloc less than they are individuals. They will head to the frontrunner like flies to a lamp.

This is nothing more than spin, from a campaign that is reeling. Josh Green's Atlantic story and Michelle Cottle's New Republic story are important for context here. The campaign has a lot of freelancing and backbiting, and also made as the signature of their effort the theme of inevitability. Well, this is what you get when things start to fall apart: more backbiting, and spin masquerading as inevitability.

Only in the Obama campaign, the fish ain't biting. While supporters may be up in arms about this, they are running their race, using their metrics, and generally working for the knockout punch. I think it's significant that Obama gave his speech on the economy yesterday at the GM plant in Janesville, hometown of Sen. Russ Feingold. Obama is trying to cut into Clinton's advantages among swing liberals and working-class populists to pave the way to the White House. While the Clinton campaign tries to bully the press.

The "govern how you campaign" theme came to a head for me yesterday with a couple things. One was that revelation in the Green article that Clinton herself was pretty insulated from the problems that were going on inside the campaign, and approving of her now-fired campaign manager Patti Solis Doyle out of loyalty, both characteristics which are trademarks of the current President. And then there's the unseemliness of this:

Last year, New York Sen. Hillary Clinton took the unusual step of renting out some of her lists. The transaction once again highlights the Clintons' connections to a businessman who now faces questions from the Securities and Exchange Commission.

Reports from Clinton's campaign show that on Dec. 3, it collected payment for renting out three mailing lists, the sale of which netted them $8,225.

But most intriguing of all was the renter of the Clinton list: a list brokerage company that is a subsidiary of one of the data-collection industry titans, Info U.S.A.

Info U.S.A.'s CEO is Vinod Gupta, a close ally of both Clintons. Gupta's empire also includes the Opinion Research Corporation, which conducts the political polling for the television network CNN.

Vin Gupta has a long history of giving and raising campaign money for the Clintons, and gave $1 million for the 2000 Millennium Celebration, a New Year's Party thrown by the Clintons.


I wouldn't want my personal information just handed over to some ally for money. It looks like an in-kind contribution, for one, and it violates privacy laws in place to protect against this kind of thing, at least in theory.

So, to sum up: the Clinton campaign isn't "declaring war" because it would be like Micronesia declaring war on America; their campaign is in a lot of trouble and these are the kind of statements made when that happened; it presages the fact that Clinton doesn't appear to be a very good manager and is willing to step right up to the ethical line; this could still be all over by March 4 no matter what Howard Wolfson or Mark Penn say.

UPDATE: Ezra:

This demonstrates not only a gross ruthlessness on the part of Clinton's campaign, but an astonishingly cavalier attitude towards the preservation of the progressive coalition. To be willing to blithely rip it to shreds in order to wrest a nomination that's not been fairly earned is not only low, but a demonstration of deeply pernicious priorities -- namely, it's an explicit statement that the campaign puts its own political success above the health of the party and the pursuit of progressive goals, and one can't but help assume that's exactly the attitude they would take towards governance, too.


I agree that they're trying to be ruthless, but the DNC is a self-preservation outfit and I can't see its members going along with ripping the party asunder when the alternative is to nominate a perfectly good candidate in Barack Obama. The rest I agree with as well.

Labels: , , , , , , ,

|

Sunday, January 06, 2008

Obamamania!

It's pretty clear that Barack Obama is going to smash the field in New Hampshire. He's up as much as 10 points in most respected polls. And Hillary's campaign is right to be nervous. They're in a very tough spot. Their campaign is reduced to having union buster Mark Penn spinning polls and lying to reporters. I agree with Kevin Drum that the way we select a President in this day and age is totally out of whack; momentum is way too important, early-state victories take complete precedence over everything else, the media actively tries to choose candidates. But it's what we have right now.

I'd be all the way down to have this be the last time we do this Iowa-New Hampshire-30 states voting in a month thing. But realistically, that's not going to happen until 2016 if a Democrat takes the White House. There isn't likely to be a contested primary on the Democratic side, and reform has only ever come from the Democrats.

I mentioned earlier that the Republican candidates where having problems figuring out a line of attack against Obama. Not so for the wingnut class, who's settled on the spectre of black people rioting if Obama loses. Now that's taking fearmongering in a whole new direction.

UPDATE: Because I'm in some kind of blog-fight with others over the relevance of California in this debate, here's some background. Let me add that I don't like the system as it is. I'd love to end it as soon as humanly possible. What I objected to was this idea that by moving up to February 5, California somehow fixed the system. They very clearly made it worse. And I objected that somehow the candidates would suddenly talk about "California issues." Let me ask this: the EPA's denial of a waiver for California to regulate greenhouse gas emissions was a major issue in the past few weeks. Has Barack Obama mentioned it? Take a look. Has Hillary Clinton? Uh-uh. John Edwards? he at least submitted testimony in favor of the waiver back in June, but lately? No.

At least Edwards has Nataline Sarkysian's family out on the campaign trail, but not in California, in New Hampshire.

I'm making a very narrow argument. If you want to blow up the system, blow it up. Don't graft on this half-measure, lie to the electorate and say everything's fixed, and perpetuate a broken system. It's really a very simple theory.

Labels: , , , , , ,

|

Friday, December 14, 2007

Penn Leaking Ink

I saw the Hardball appearance that Ezra Klein references as well, and it was riveting. I don't know if I'd ever seen Mark Penn live on television before, and he was uniformly awful, especially when he tried to not-so-subtly bring up Obama's cocaine use again. Joe Trippi called him on it immediately, and it became a total mess. Here's Ezra:

My hunch, right now, is that if Clinton goes down, Penn is going to be blamed. You can see the knives coming out already, but he really does a poor job here, and he's hampered not merely by his shortcomings as a speaker, but by the absence of message within the Clinton campaign. When the rationale for your campaign is that you're the frontrunner with the experience to win, losing your lead in the polls doesn't only put you in second place, it actually shreds the argument for your candidacy. What we're beginning to see here is how underdeveloped the arguments for Clinton were when separated from her aura of inevitability.


You can also see Trippi trying to position Edwards as above the fray of a Clinton-Obama food fight, and apparently Iowans are buying that. But it's not really true. It's a one-sided food fight, with the Clintons flailing away in an old style of politics. This is because, as Ezra notes, there's no rationale for her campaign. She's running on the name Clinton, as a re-election campaign, more than anything else. I made this argument earlier this week, that her candidacy is entirely about how she's in first place. It's really Iowa or bust for Clinton, and it didn't have to be that way. That's entirely a fault of positioning, and a fault of Mark Penn.

Labels: , , , , ,

|

Friday, November 09, 2007

Just a Bunch of Coinkydinks

When Hillary Clinton's top strategist Mark Penn was revealed to be the head of Burson-Marsteller, a PR firm that has union-busters as clients, I figured, "Hey, he's the head of the company, maybe a couple of the clients got by him." When it turned out that the firm did public relations work for Blackwater leading up to Erik Prince's Congressional testimony, I thought, "Look, he's distracted, he's running Hillary's campaign, he can't be on top of everything." When I saw the firm working for corrupt Pakistani pols, I said "Hmm..."

I'm beginning to think that the world's worst client list is not an accident.

Burson Marsteller, the PR/lobbying firm run by Hillary Clinton's chief strategist, Mark Penn, is handling crisis management for the owner of Aqua Dots, the bead toys with an adhesive coating that too easily turns into the date-rape drug, GHB.

A source directly familiar with the arrangement confirms that Aqua Dots' manufacturer, SpinMaster, based in Canada, has turned to Burson Marsteller for help.

An official of the company said that Penn has no role in the Aqua Dots contract.

"There are over 2000 clients," a company official said. "Mark had no contact with them in any way."


Far too many of these clients are shady or downright harmful. If the directive from the top is to "spin whatever you can get paid to spin" without thought of ethics or principle, then this is what you get. Mark Penn is absolutely culpable. And by extension, so is Hillary, honestly.

No more corporate Democrats.

Labels: , , , ,

|

Wednesday, October 31, 2007

If I Have To Spend Eight Years Listening To Mark Penn...

Just kill me.



Welcome to your time machine. A Hillary Clinton presidency will be eight more years of parsing and waffling and incomplete thoughts. Look, just come out and say it. She didn't want a press release that said "Hillary Wants To Give Illegals Candy." But that press release will happen anyway, so what's the point? Why not try to get OUT IN FRONT of an issue for a change.

In the absence of any leadership on immigration from the left, the issue has been demagogued to death. I heard a guy last night on right-wing radio talking about how his tax refund was lower than ever this year, and blaming illegals for it. Uh, the federal government sets tax policy, not Jose Jimenez, and they've been redistributing wealth upwards for decades. There's serious concern among the middle class about their economic future, and this has been seized upon by nativists. It's the precarious underbelly of right-wing populism, and this radio caller's comment was the distilled essence of it. They think they're not getting ahead because the illegals are taking their jobs and sucking up government services because they have no "survival skills" (a direct quote). Survival skills are ALL that a Mexican national travelling through deserts and rivers to feed his family has. They're contributing more to the economy than they're taking away, and they're being exploited by cruel and greedy employers. Fix that part of the issue, which has been degraded severely in the Bush era, and you fix it all.

Someone needs to be giving voice to the voiceless and fighting for an immigration reform that is sensible and reflects American principles. Hillary Clinton and her spinners offer nothing but mush. She won the AFSCME endorsement today, so that'll probably overshadow last night's pathetic performance. And her team will probably be successful in framing it as "6 guys ganging up to attack 1 woman" (uh, it's called being the frontrunner, if you don't like it, drop out). But we need more than status quo, follow the polls, mushy-middle technocracy. There are too many challenges we face for that to characterize the next 8 years.

Labels: , , , , , , ,

|

Friday, October 05, 2007

It's On Like Donkey Kong

John Edwards saw an opening today and he took it.

In a scathing attack, Democratic presidential candidate John Edwards went after front-runner Sen. Hillary Clinton, D-N.Y., Friday, calling her a "corporate Democrat," comparing top Clinton campaign strategist Mark Penn to former Bush aide Karl Rove and assailing Penn's ties to Blackwater USA, the embattled private firm of military contractors accused by the Iraqi government of firing upon and killing 11 unarmed Iraqi civilians last month.

"Bush has been a perfect example of cronyism because Blackwater has given hundreds of thousands of dollars to Republicans and to President Bush," Edwards said in an interview with the Associated Press while campaigning in Iowa. "I also saw this morning that Sen. Clinton's primary adviser, Mark Penn, who is like her Karl Rove -- his firm is representing Blackwater."

Edwards said that he thinks "it is important for Iowa caucus-goers to understand the choices they have in this election. And it is the reason I continue to say we don't want to replace a group of corporate Republicans with a group of corporate Democrats. I think it is important for caucus-goers to see this choice."


The Clinton camp is going to call this dirty pool, but it's really not. It's completely fair game to note the public affairs of advisors to a Presidential campaign, particularly top advisors. And the face that Hillary Clinton's top advisor not only represents union-busting firms but also Blackwater USA is significant. The union folks who have declined hitting Clinton for this missed a huge opportunity, not to take her down, but to stop Burson-Marsteller's union-busting clients, or at least get B-M to drop them. John Edwards is not making the same mistake.

Mark Penn just became a HUGE issue in this campaign.

An official with a rival Democratic campaign added to Edwards' remarks, saying that "when people are asking themselves who can better change the way things are going, Penn is a massive liability. How can you fight for change when you've got someone fighting to keep things exactly as they are on health care, with subprime lenders, and even in Iraq?"

Penn has often come under fire for his company's clients, whose goals are often at odds with liberal politics. Burson has also represented oil and tobacco companies, and worked for corporations to impede union organizing events, about which labor leaders expressed "distress" in a letter to Clinton. Penn said he played no role in any of the anti-union activities. Burson has also represented Countrywide Financial, a subprime loan company also under fire.


Frankly this should have been an issue long before. But now it's exploding into the open at a time when the primary season is in full swing.

Labels: , , , ,

|

Blackwater: Military Hates Them, Hillary's Pollster Loves Them

The biggest argument you can make against Blackwater USA is that they harm the military effort in Iraq through their recklessness, which ends up boomeranging back on our troops. Now the military is agreeing with that assessment publicly:

U.S. military reports from the scene of the Sept. 16 shooting incident involving the security firm Blackwater USA indicate that its guards opened fire without provocation and used excessive force against Iraqi civilians, according to a senior U.S. military official.

The reports came to light as an Interior Ministry official and five eyewitnesses described a second deadly shooting minutes after the incident in Nisoor Square. The same Blackwater security guards, after driving about 150 yards away from the square, fired into a crush of cars, killing one person and injuring two, the Iraqi official said.

The U.S. military reports appear to corroborate the Iraqi government's contention that Blackwater was at fault in the shooting incident in Nisoor Square, in which hospital records say at least 14 people were killed and 18 were wounded.

"It was obviously excessive, it was obviously wrong," said the U.S. military official, who spoke on condition of anonymity because the incident remains the subject of several investigations. "The civilians that were fired upon, they didn't have any weapons to fire back at them. And none of the IP or any of the local security forces fired back at them," he added, using a military abbreviation for the Iraqi police. The Blackwater guards appeared to have fired grenade launchers in addition to machine guns, the official said.


Only the State Department's initial report has failed to corroborate this explanation of the attack, and that one was written by a Blackwater contractor.

Despite the initial report, the State Department is coming around to the reality that changes are needed to the private contractor security situation in Iraq. They are recommending major changes aimed at increasing oversight on security personnel, essentially guarding the guards. Boy, that's good value for our taxpayer money.

Of course, Blackwater isn't taking this news lying down. They're fighting back, particularly on the PR front, by hiring the powerful and connected firm Burson-Marsteller to do their crisis management. Burson-Marsteller, by the way, is run by Mark Penn, who is pretty much in charge of the Hillary Clinton campaign.

WASHINGTON (AP) — Public relations giant Burson-Marsteller has vast experience steering companies through tough times. But there's a limit to how much it can help Blackwater USA, a new client that's been battered by negative publicity.

The State Department, which pays Blackwater hundreds of millions of dollars to protect U.S. diplomats in Iraq, has stringent rules barring the private security contractor from discussing with the media the details of its work, according to those familiar with the arrangement.

Under those limitations, it's difficult to repair a corporate image, said one official close to Blackwater [...]

Burson-Marsteller was brought aboard by the Washington law firms representing Blackwater — McDermott Will & Emery and Crowell & Moring.

One of the executives on the Blackwater account is Robert Tappan, a former State Department official. Tappan is a managing director of BKSH & Associates Worldwide, a Burson-Marsteller subsidiary.


The company claims that the relationship was temporary and has now ended. But if the braindead media wanted to push a story on Hillary, I don't think her laugh would be the one. How about the fact that her strategist is running a company that does business with the thuggish mercenary army that is destroying our reputation in Iraq single-handedly?

Labels: , , , , , , ,

|