Amazon.com Widgets

As featured on p. 218 of "Bloggers on the Bus," under the name "a MyDD blogger."

Friday, April 06, 2007

No Relationship

There are still PLENTY of Bush defenders who insist, as the Vice President did yesterday, that Saddam Hussein had a working relationship with Al Qaeda. That list got one smaller yesterday, as the Defense Department's report on Doug Feith's alternative intelligence shop revealed this:

...the inspector general's report, in a footnote, commented that it is "noteworthy . . . that post-war debriefs of Sadaam Hussein, [former Iraqi foreign minister] Tariq Aziz, [former Iraqi intelligence minister Mani al-Rashid] al Tikriti, and [senior al-Qaeda operative Ibn al-Shaykh] al-Libi, as well as document exploitation by [the Defense Intelligence Agency] all confirmed that the Intelligence Community was correct: Iraq and al-Qaida did not cooperate in all categories" alleged by Feith's office.

From these sources, the report added, "the terms the Intelligence Community used to describe the relationship between Iraq and al-Qaida were validated, [namely] 'no conclusive signs,' and 'direct cooperation . . . has not been established.' "


So the CIA was right all along in describing the relationship between Iraq and Al Qaeda as nonexistent. In 2002 putting that question to the public would probably get 80-90% in the affirmative, because it was a central case for war. Even NOW it's a central case for staying, indirectly, as the spin goes that because of September 11, we cannot leave a safe haven for terrorists, yadda yadda yadda (Even though, of course, there are vast swaths of Waziristan which are, you know, safe havens for terrorists). The truth is that it was all wrapped up into a big lie, and a KNOWING one, as the intelligence community was well aware that there was no collaborative relationship, in addition to their doubts about WMD. This is the strongest indication yet that Doug Feith's shop was literally designed to rewrite history, to fix the intelligence around the policy. More than anything, this is why there will be no second chance on Iraq with the American public. It's because it began in bad faith, and so it will end the same way.

Labels: , , , , , ,

|

Friday, February 09, 2007

Inappropriate

A new report from the Inspector General at the Pentagon is trying hard to split the baby, calling the Office of Special Plans, Douglas Feith's intelligence shop run out of the Defense Department, inappropriate but not illegal. This is mainly so news headlines can say "Prewar intelligence not illegal". Me, I agree with BooMan.

Well, no shit. It's not illegal to be fucking crazy, but it sure is inappropriate to hire crazy people to run the most powerful killing machine in the history of mankind. Thanks a lot for that clarification, Inspector General.

As for the legality of disseminating intelligence reports without dissenting views attached, that can get kind of tricky. Obviously it goes against all standard practice in the area of intelligence. It's a bad idea and should never, ever be done. And if it is done, no one should take the product seriously and they should go to the press and reveal that crazed bloodthirsty bastards have taken over a segment of the government and are going to get upwards of a million innocent people killed if someone doesn't stop them.


What the Office of Special Plans did, let's say, OUGHT to be illegal. Feith ran an off-the-books intelligence operation that was designed to collect particular bits of intelligence supporting the case for war. In other words, the conclusions were made first, then the intelligence was found to support it. In the process, Feith and his team twisted the facts to show that Iraq and Saddam were in league with Al Qaeda, which was false; allowed for no dissenting viewpoints on that assessment, though the consensus of the intelligence community was the opposite; and sent that assessment to the White House, where it was used to make the case for war.

What we have is an absolute hijacking of the intelligence process, a palace coup where ideologues reach foregone conclusions and do whatever it takes to implement their nefarious schemes. And this report can say all it wants, but at least one member of Congress thinks it is illegal:

“The IG has concluded that this office was engaged in intelligence activities. The Senate Intelligence Committee was never informed of these activities. Whether these actions were authorized or not, it appears that they were not in compliance with the law.

“In the coming days, I will carefully review all aspects of the report and will consult with Vice Chairman Bond to determine whether any additional action by the Senate Intelligence Committee is warranted."


Whether or not this violates the National Security Act of 1947 hangs on whether this was an intelligence assessment or simply criticism of the intelligence of the time. The report clearly calls it an assessment. Doug Feith should be in jail.

The summary judgments of this report should be available soon. And there's a hearing going on about this very issue in the Senate Armed Services Committee today. But it's extremely important that this is front-page news. Especially now, when we're seeing the same kind of intelligence-cooking with regard to Iran, and the same kind of uncritical thinking from the media.

SEVILLE, Spain - Serial numbers and markings on explosives used in Iraq provide “pretty good” evidence that Iran is providing either weapons or technology for militants there, Defense Secretary Robert Gates asserted Friday.

Ooooh. Seems pretty scary. Sounds factual. Authoritative, even. And the second paragraph…

Offering some of the first public details of evidence the military has collected, Gates said, “I think there’s some serial numbers, there may be some markings on some of the projectile fragments that we found,” that point to Iran.


Supposition continues to be stated as fact by the Administration, and reported as fact in the press. That's more than inappropriate. It's criminal.

Labels: , , , , , ,

|