Amazon.com Widgets

As featured on p. 218 of "Bloggers on the Bus," under the name "a MyDD blogger."

Monday, July 20, 2009

New Civil War!

Those defending the Honduran government for rousting the democratically elected President out of bed and into a plane leaving the country and installing a new leader always claim that Mel Zelaya was attempted to subvert the Constitution by seeking a second term, justifying the coup. Clearly, then, if Zelaya would give up that claim and agree to even earlier elections than required by law, there could be some common ground, right? As long as the Constitution was defended and all that. But no:

Talks to resolve the coup crisis in Honduras collapsed Sunday after the de facto government refused a mediator's proposal to reinstate ousted President Manuel Zelaya.

The failure of negotiations under the direction of Costa Rican President Oscar Arias dashed the most promising diplomatic effort aimed at ending the crisis and raised the specter of more violence.

"What is the alternative to dialogue?" a disappointed Arias said in San Jose, the Costa Rican capital. "Possibly . . . there could be a civil war, or bloodshed, that the Honduran people do not deserve." [...]

Carlos Lopez, representing the de facto Honduran government as foreign minister, said it would not agree to the brief reinstatement of Zelaya, the first of seven points proposed by Arias.

"I am very sorry," Lopez said to Arias, "but the proposals you have presented are unacceptable."

He said efforts to reinstate "petitioning citizen Mr. Zelaya" represented foreign interference in Honduran affairs. He likened Zelaya's purported violation of the Honduran Constitution to "a woman being raped by the person obliged to defend her."


So much for understatement!

In addition to reinstating Zelaya, the deal would have moved up elections, installed a "national unity government" with new cabinet ministers from all major parties, and gave amnesty for any coup-related crimes. That's everything the coup plotters say they wanted. What they actually sought was power through the barrel of a gun.

Labels: , , ,

|

Saturday, May 16, 2009

The End Of Conventional Warfare

You may not hear a lot about it, but one of the longest civil wars in world history may come to an end this weekend, as the government of Sri Lanka claims to have defeated the Tamil Tiger rebels on the battlefield. However, the rebel leaders remain at large. The government has control of the coastline, confining the rebels to a small patch of land. The best part of this is that civilians who were caught in the middle of the conflict have poured across the front lines and appear to be out of danger. Small comfort to the 7,000 civilians who have died this year.

It seems like the fatal mistake for the Tamil Tigers came when they engaged the government in conventional warfare. Having lost, they will probably just revert back to the expected guerrilla tactics. The future of modern warfare will go pretty much like this, and I don't know that counter-insurgency has proved so successful that we have figured out a remedy here.

Labels: , ,

|

Thursday, June 12, 2008

The Civil War Acceleration Program

Oh goody, let's pay and arm more Iraqis with sectarian viewpoints and little interest in reconciliation.

Young men armed and paid by the U.S. military took to the streets of the Iraqi capital's Sadr City area for the first time Wednesday to guard their neighborhoods, part of a new strategy designed to recruit former Shiite militiamen to American-created security groups, U.S. officials said [...]

Toting AK-47 assault rifles for a $300-a-month salary, the young men are viewed by U.S. officials as the best way to address a dearth of security forces in Sadr City, the site of bitter clashes this spring between U.S. forces and militiamen loyal to anti-American cleric Moqtada al-Sadr. The officials hope the initiative will lead some militia supporters away from violence by paying them to protect the area.

But even officers helping to create the program acknowledge there is risk in supplying weapons to men who may have recently encouraged violence against U.S. troops. "Are these guys all going to be lily-white angels? No," said Maj. Byron Sarchet, information operations officer for the brigade responsible for Sadr City. "We need to tread lightly."


There's something unsettling about an armed Shiite, likely to be a Mahdi Army sympathizer or even a member, maintaining order through the barrel of a gun saying "We are here to protect our neighborhood and make sure the militias don't take control." Uh, that would be the DEFINITION of a militia member. And setting this up so that young unemployed Shiites have loyalty only to their paycheck portends disaster. It also is another way in which Bush is trying to force a permanent presence in Iraq. If we stop paying these patrols, chaos will ensue. So we must stay, and keep paying.

Here's a taste of how this could blow up in our faces:

Not all Iraqis agree. Lt. Col. Yehiye Rasul Abdullah, commander of the Iraqi army battalion in Jamila, recoiled at the idea of working with supporters of Mahdi Army fighters who killed his soldiers.

"Those who have contributed to the spilling of Iraqi blood, we will never accept them," he said after coming to check on the guards.


So when the Iraqis do send the US military packing, what is going to become of all these heavily armed foes of the government and the government security forces who hold them in contempt?

It's like we're shaking up a bunch of soda bottles and just waiting for them to explode.

Labels: , , , , ,

|

Saturday, April 12, 2008

The Mess In Zimbabwe

The opposition party Movement for Democratic Change is now vowing to boycott a runoff vote:

The 50 members of the opposition's National Executive Committee voted unanimously that they believed their presidential candidate, Morgan Tsvangirai, won the March 29 vote by the clear majority needed for a first-round victory, said party spokesman Nelson Chamisa. A second round of voting, he said, would only encourage Mugabe to redouble efforts to rig the results and intimidate opposition supporters.

"We have resolved that we will not participate," Chamisa said. "There won't be any runoff. We have won."

Chamisa declined to say how Tsvangirai intended to assume the presidency in a country with no history of peaceful transfers of power.


There's going to be a civil war in Zimbabwe. I think that's perfectly clear. The ruling party led by Robert Mugabe has already begun the crackdown, banning political rallies and arresting MDC Presidential candidate Morgan Tsvangirai's lawyer, along with about 1,000 of his supporters. The State Department is making vague calls for a peaceable solution, but they are not beginning from the assumption that a brutal war is inevitable, and Mugabe's forces are perfectly willing to disappear or kill every rival.

Right now there aren't many places, not even Iraq, more needing of the world's attention than Zimbabwe.

Labels: , , , ,

|

Thursday, March 27, 2008

Fill 'Er Up

That's the thing about attacking a popular militia group in the most oil-rich city in the country, they have options:

Saboteurs blew up one of Iraq’s two main oil export pipelines in southern Iraq on Thursday, a Southern Oil Company official told Reuters.

”This morning saboteurs blew up the pipeline transporting crude from Zubair 1 by placing bombs beneath it. The pipeline was severely damaged,” the official said, speaking on condition of anonymity.


This will probably stall 1/3 of all oil exports out of Basra. And the Mahdi Army made intimations that this would be their next move, so this is obviously a result of the Maliki invasion.

Meanwhile, Baghdad is so safe that a spokesman for the security plan has been abducted. And the battles have widened to the entire Shi'a region between Baghdad and Basra. The Mahdi Army "opened fire on civilians in downtown Baghdad," which doesn't seem like the actions of a group under cease-fire. After all the "success" of the surge, we're back to open warfare on the streets of Iraq. Tell me again how we're winning?

...Apparently Bush said in a speech today that "the groundwork had been laid for political reconciliation." Only the ground is covered in oil from the blown pipeline and the blood of martyrs, I guess.

Labels: , , , , , ,

|

Tuesday, March 25, 2008

The Great Unraveling

Iraq is actually falling apart on all sides. There's a reason that Gen. Petraeus and Ryan Crocker are calling for a pause in drawing down troop levels. There are major fires burning on both sides of the sectarian divide.

As I discussed last week, substantial numbers of the Sunni Awakening groups are contemplating a general strike, frustrated with delays in cash payments and the refusal of the central Shiite government to integrate them into the Iraqi security forces. Marc Lynch has been tracking these increasing problems.

Because I've written so very much about this I'm not going to belabor the point, other than to repeat that this isn't just an unfortunate development in an otherwise sound approach. It's structural, and gets to the essence of the strategic failure of the surge. The Awakenings strategy was a smart, tactically successful adaptation to developments on the ground, and Petraeus's team has done the best it could with the hand it was dealt. But it has always been the case that the Awakenings strategy built up military power outside of the Iraqi state, and has never had a plausible theory of how that power would be harnessed into a unified, legitimate state. It achieved some of its short-term tactical ends, but worked against the strategic goal of creating an effectively sovereign Iraqi state with a security architecture sustainable without US forces.


Lynch thinks the US should give Nouri al-Maliki an ultimatum to stop payments to these Sunni groups and transfer the responsibility to the Ministries of Interior or Defense (who can use all that oil money the government is hoarding), because without integration there will never be a hope to reconcile the disparate sectarian groups and instead you'll simply have this extra-governmental armed force. But as the Bush Administration's goal is merely to keep a lid on violence until the next President takes over, that's not likely to happen.

As for keeping a lid on violence, this is extremely worrisome.

A cease-fire critical to the improved security situation in Iraq appeared to unravel Monday when a militia loyal to radical Shiite Muslim cleric Muqtada al Sadr began shutting down neighborhoods in west Baghdad and issuing demands of the central government.

Simultaneously, in the strategic southern port city of Basra, where Sadr's Mahdi militia is in control, the Iraqi government launched a crackdown in the face of warnings by Sadr's followers that they'll fight government forces if any Sadrists are detained. By 1 a.m. Arab satellite news channels reported clashes between the Mahdi Army and police in Basra.

The freeze on offensive activity by Sadr's Mahdi Army has been a major factor behind the recent drop in violence in Iraq, and there were fears that the confrontation that's erupted in Baghdad and Basra could end the lull in attacks, assassinations, kidnappings and bombings.


The fighting in Basra show the intra-Shiite tensions bubbling over between the Sadrists and Shiite government forces, which is breaking down into such a bloodbath that the US is asking for a British surge in the south to deal with the splintering. What's actually more worrisome is the nationwide civil disobedience called for by Muqtada al-Sadr. In protest of the American and Iraqi forces taking advantage of his cease-fire to arrest Mahdi Army members, Sadr is closing down stores and having his supporters pour into the streets. Without a history of Martin Luther King-like civil disobedience in the country, I can't see how this remains nonviolent.

Now the million dollar question is: what is "a nationwide civil disobedience campaign?" If it is strikes and protests that's one thing. But if it is the beginning of the end of the ceasefire that is something very different. We have to wait and see.

But the issue is very serious. In fact it's huge. The drop in violence in Iraq has generally been attributed to four elements 1) More American forces and the change in tactics to counterinsurgency; 2) The Awakening movement; 3) The Sadr ceasfire; and 4) The ethnic cleansing and physical separation of the various sides.

It's hard to say for sure, which of these factors was the most important. The Bush Administration will tell you it's all about the troop levels. I've tended to believe it's more of a mix and was most inclined towards the Anbar Awakening and the sectarian cleansing as the important factors. But when you look at the data it really seems to indicate that the Sadr ceasefire may have been the key.


And that ceasefire is tenuous in the environment of a general strike and civil disobedience. If and when the Iraqi security forces imprison and punish, or God forbid scatter bullets at the striking Sadrists, would ANYONE expect a calm and measured response?

Of course not. And since nobody suffers more than George Bush for all the death and destruction in Iraq, expect him to bear the burden even more in the coming months. Their goal is of course to keep the country together just long enough to blame the eventual failure on somebody else, but it appears that events on the ground are overtaking that strategy.

Labels: , , , , , , , , , ,

|

Sunday, December 16, 2007

Over In The Forgotten War

Speaking of Iraq, it turns out that the military understands that their only chance to keep the lid off the cauldron is to keep every available troop in Baghdad.

In a change of plans, American commanders in Iraq have decided to keep their forces concentrated in Baghdad when the buildup strategy ends next year, removing troops instead from outlying areas of the country.

The change represents the military's first attempt to confront its big challenge in 2008: how to cut the number of troops without sacrificing security.

The shift in deployment strategy, described by senior U.S. military officials in Iraq and Washington, is based on concerns that despite recent improvements, the capital could again erupt into widespread violence without an imposing American military presence.


Smells like progress!

The worst part of this is what it presages. By taking troops out of the outlying areas, particularly in the Sunni triangle around Anbar province, you're essentially ceding that territory over to well-armed militias.

The new planning is not without risk and controversy. The change in U.S. deployment strategy is likely to shift the balance of political power in Iraq by putting much greater authority over provincial affairs in the hands of local and regional officials. That will increase their influence and offset the authority of the Shiite-dominated central government in Baghdad.


That basically creates the soft partition that Joe Biden is always screaming about. But it's not that simple. The Sunnis in Anbar actually want a return to national rule. With the aid of American money and know-how, the Sunnis are organizing themselves into a force that threatens the Maliki government.

Officers who've served in Iraq warn that the Great Awakening could be transitory. "The Sunni insurgents are following a 'fight, bargain, subvert, fight' approach to get what they want," said one colonel. So Americans need to explore whether U.S. forces are courting long-term strategic success, or if the expedient cash surge is leading U.S. forces into a new phase of conflict that could engulf the region and create a perfect storm.


We're playing with a lot of fire. We have the Shiite forces biding their time, led by a ruthless group of young militiamen. We have Turkey routinely incurring into Iraqi air space, with the help of the US military, to pound PKK rebels, and at any point that conflict has the potential to turn into another front of the war. Meanwhile the actual military strategy is to push the Shiites and Sunnis into further conflict:

The new U.S. military view worries officials in the Iraqi government who fear their power will be diminished. The ruling Shiite Muslim bloc already has expressed concern over U.S. plans to hand over security responsibilities to recently recruited police forces, particularly in Sunni Muslim strongholds such as Anbar where the new officers are mostly Sunnis.

But the day-to-day commander in Iraq, Army Lt. Gen. Raymond T. Odierno, and his staff believe that the increasing competence of provincial security and political leaders will put pressure on the government in Baghdad that "will breed a better central government," said his chief of staff, Brig. Gen. Joseph Anderson.

"There are different schools of thought here," Anderson said in an interview in his office at the U.S. military headquarters at Camp Victory, outside the capital. "Our school of thought is provincial capacity will ultimately lead to enhanced central government capacity. That's our view."


That's madness. This isn't a situation where you can run ads or try to pick off certain legislators in elections. This is a thousand year-old struggle at the root, and there's a fine line between pressuring the central government and antagonizing them. I know that media figures and politicians fly into Baghdad, hence the reason to keep that area relatively under control. But this is being done at the expense of long-term stability, and if that falls through, you have heavily armed camps ready for civil war. This is bad.

Labels: , , , , , , , , ,

|

Wednesday, December 12, 2007

Things Are Not Good

Al Qaeda killed as many as 62 people yesterday in a double car bombing at the offices of the UN High Commission for Refugees in Algiers.

This morning in Lebanon an Army general in line to be the main commander was killed in a car bombing, as the country moves even closer to civil war.

And dozens are dead, maybe up to 60, and that's a preliminary report, in a spate of car bombs in southern Iraq, in a Shiite stronghold called Amarra. And it's unclear whether the Shiite factions battling for power in this region are to blame, or a Sunni insurgent.

Sometimes you get the feeling that the world is going up in flames. This is one of those mornings.

Labels: , , , , , ,

|

Monday, November 05, 2007

This Is Really Unbelievable

And it's happening with almost no media attention.

Despite their rhetoric about not wanting to hand President Bush another “blank check” for the Iraq War, Democrats appear poised to give him exactly that — enough cash to keep the war going full steam for as long as six months, no strings attached.

Democratic leaders continue to fear GOP attacks that cutting off or slowing funds would hurt the troops, despite anger among the Democratic base over the party’s failure to use Congress’ power of the purse to end the war.


We've gone from "the only thing we have to fear is fear itself" to "Democratic leaders continue to fear GOP attacks." What's that line about how society is always evolving?

The worst thing about this quiet, craven capitulation is that is doesn't even make the effort to provide the public with any context for what is happening in Iraq, ceding the entire landscape to the "we're winning" reverse-Chicken Littles who constantly maintain that the sky is not falling. The truth is that the surge is not meeting its stated goal of bringing factions together for a political reconciliation, and any more stalling there could lead to the Sunnis rejoining the insurgency, according to a top Army Colonel.

Stanton believes Shiite reluctance to bring the so-called Concerned Local Citizens into the formal security forces and to hold provincial elections -- expected to benefit the Sunnis, who boycotted the last round of provincial voting in 2005 -- might guarantee precisely the result that the Shiites fear. "How long before all of these people trying to reconcile get discouraged at the continuous rebuff and come up with their own Plan B?" he asked. Plan B, Stanton assessed, might be either formal secession or to "pick up insurgency again." When I asked what the timetable might be for the Sunni Concerned Local Citizens to go to Plan B, he replied, "God, man, if I knew that, I'd be so much happier with my job than I am right now."


So the situation is still fragile, and made worse by the looming presence of an occupying force with a massive embassy, which at least gives the appearance of controlling the strings of the government. Some metrics for providing basic services are up, and that's great, but the question remains whether or not it's too late. And what's completely uncertain is whether this new strategy is just putting a lid on violence that will blow over once we run out of troops, or... or what? Nobody can articulate what the hell it IS doing.

The problem for these Democratic leaders is that, by saying nothing, their arguments grow stale in a very fluid situation.

Ezra Klein recently reminded me of Fafblog's classic "Fafblog Interviews the Democratic Party" post which, in turn, was a reminder of how lame 2005-vintage Democratic thinking about Iraq was. Over time, though, that thinking improved, which is a good thing. Nevertheless, Iraq is a constantly changing situation and when in early 2007 Bush rejected the verdict of the American people and the Baker-Hamilton Commission, much of the previous wave of proposals became irrelevant to the future debate.

But unlike on other issues, neither Hillary Clinton nor any of her rivals could afford to wait before talking about their plans for Iraq. As a result, the frontrunner has a stated position on Iraq today that's really based on the year-old Baker-Hamilton proposals. Worse, because nobody wants to be seen as "flip-flopping" and because everyone knows you tack left during the primaries and then right during the general election, she's all-but-guaranteed to have a platform in October 2008 that was really designed for the circumstances of December 2006 and doesn't reflect either the evolving situation on the ground or the evolving thinking of policy people, including some of her own advisors.


It's worse for the Democrats in Congress, who've been silent long enough that the "surge is working" myth has become embedded at least in media retellings of the war, making it harder to catch up to where we actually are on the battlefield.

Labels: , , , , , , ,

|

Monday, October 22, 2007

Hearts And Minds At 30,000 Feet

If it feels like I've done this story before, it's because I have. We continue to try and wage a counterinsurgency campaign with massive bombing that defeats the entire purpose of counterinsurgency, which is to get the population on your side. The reason for the bombing is that it requires less personnel, and also airpower is the only thing keeping the country from a full-on sectarian civil war. You have this lie of "precision bombing" being perpetuated:

In Iraq, the temporary increase of 30,000 U.S. troops ordered by President Bush in January has led to the increase in bombing missions. The U.S. command has moved forces off large bases and into neighborhoods and has launched several large offensives aimed at al-Qaeda.

"You end up having that many more opportunities for close air support," said Air Force Brig. Gen. Stephen Mueller, director of the Combined Air Operations Center in Doha, Qatar.

More precise targeting and smaller bombs have made it easier for the Air Force to support ground troops in counterinsurgencies, such as those in Afghanistan and Iraq.

"We're hitting within 15 feet of where we're aiming," Mueller said. A typical 500-pound bomb is 50% explosives, but newer versions carry about 100 pounds of explosives.

Some bombs are "designed to take one building and not the whole block," Mueller said.


Which I guess means that the Air Force was targeting the children:

Bombs struck Shiite targets in Baghdad on Monday, killing at least seven people and wounding two dozen, and an adviser to a prominent Sunni politician was gunned down in a western section of the capital, police said.

The blasts occurred a day after the U.S. military said its forces killed an estimated 49 militants during a dawn raid to capture an Iranian-linked militia chief in Baghdad's Sadr City Shiite enclave, one of the highest tolls for a single operation since President Bush declared an end to active combat in 2003. The U.S. military said the militia chief was not captured or killed.

Iraqi police and hospital officials, who often overstate casualties, reported only 15 deaths including three children. Iraqi government spokesman Ali al-Dabbagh said all the dead were civilians.

The U.S. military said it was not aware of any civilian casualties, and the discrepancy in the death tolls and accounts of what happened could not be reconciled. American commanders reported no U.S. casualties.


Bombs are never going to be as precision-targeted as the US military claims. That's just ludicrous. And so expanding the air war five-fold increases by five-fold the chances of civilian casualties, which turns the population against the occupation, and sends them scurrying for anywhere the US isn't bombing. Some of them have made their way to Kurdistan where they may face another fresh hell. The Iraqi government has joined the Afghan government before them and strongly condemned these continued air attacks and begged for them to stop. We are literally bombing Iraq back into the Stone Age. It's the most underreported facet of the occupation.

There's a strain of thought that casualties are actually going up in Baghdad and down in the parts of the country we're US forces have left. I don't think it's that cut and dried, but clearly American airpower is really the only big stick we can wield to stop more civilian strife. Yet that will backfire as well.

Labels: , , , , ,

|

Monday, October 08, 2007

Hope In Iraq Loses By Three Falls, No Submissions

I agree with K-Drum, this is both game, set, and match:

For much of this year, the U.S. military strategy in Iraq has sought to reduce violence so that politicians could bring about national reconciliation, but several top Iraqi leaders say they have lost faith in that broad goal.

Iraqi leaders argue that sectarian animosity is entrenched in the structure of their government. Instead of reconciliation, they now stress alternative and perhaps more attainable goals: streamlining the government bureaucracy, placing experienced technocrats in positions of authority and improving the dismal record of providing basic services.

"I don't think there is something called reconciliation, and there will be no reconciliation as such," said Deputy Prime Minister Barham Salih, a Kurd. "To me, it is a very inaccurate term. This is a struggle about power."

Humam Hamoudi, a prominent Shiite cleric and parliament member, said any future reconciliation would emerge naturally from an efficient, fair government, not through short-term political engineering among Sunnis and Shiites.

"Reconciliation should be a result and not a goal by itself," he said. "You should create the atmosphere for correct relationships, and not wave slogans that 'I want to reconcile with you.' "


But a fair and efficient government without a reconciliation between the warring factions will not be possible. It would be impossible to deliver basic services to the Old Confederacy from Washington in 1863, or in Lebanon in the 1980s or Guatemala or any of the war-torn countries experiencing Civil War. You can streamline the bureaucracy and fill ministerial posts all you want, if people are shooting at the garbagemen, they're not going to pick up the garbage. So this really is a call to fight it out in the street and let the spoils go to the victor. It's a declaration of civil war, which has been raging undeclared up until now.

Labels: , ,

|

Tuesday, September 04, 2007

Because Republicans Are Great At Bottom-Up Democracy

You're starting to see a lot of chatter among war defenders about "mini-benchmarks" and "bottom-up reconciliation." The idea is really based on Sunni tribes turning on extremists in Anbar completely by themselves, which apparently will repeat itself throughout the country. Indeed, the White House is trying to capitalize on this by providing more in aid to Iraqi Sunnis in Anbar, and indeed yesterday's Presidential visit was to Anbar Province.

Here's the thing, though. This "bottom-up" strategy is made-up. There's no political reconciliation going on at all. This is about completely segregating all parts of Iraq and winding up with a heavily armed group of Shiites and Sunnis and Kurds all fiercely protecting their own turf. That's not a country, and it certainly doesn't presage that the central government will ever be able to function. We're moving toward Joe Biden's three-state solution by default. And these would be three violent, theocratic, sectarian states, who undoubtedly would eventually come into conflict with one another using the arms we provided them all.

Thousands of other Sunnis like Kamal have been cleared out of the western half of Baghdad, which they once dominated, in recent months. The surge of U.S. troops—meant in part to halt the sectarian cleansing of the Iraqi capital—has hardly stemmed the problem. The number of Iraqi civilians killed in July was slightly higher than in February, when the surge began. According to the Iraqi Red Crescent, the number of internally displaced persons (IDPs) has more than doubled to 1.1 million since the beginning of the year, nearly 200,000 of those in Baghdad governorate alone. Rafiq Tschannen, chief of the Iraq mission for the International Organization for Migration, says that the fighting that accompanied the influx of U.S. troops actually "has increased the IDPs to some extent."

When Gen. David Petraeus goes before Congress next week to report on the progress of the surge, he may cite a decline in insurgent attacks in Baghdad as one marker of success. In fact, part of the reason behind the decline is how far the Shiite militias' cleansing of Baghdad has progressed: they've essentially won. "If you look at pre-February 2006, there were only a couple of areas in the city that were unambiguously Shia," says a U.S. official in Baghdad who is familiar with the issue but is not authorized to speak on the record. "That's definitely not the case anymore." The official says that "the majority, more than half" of Baghdad's neighborhoods are now Shiite-dominated, a judgment echoed in the most recent National Intelligence Estimate on Iraq: "And very few are mixed." In places like Amel, pockets of Sunnis live in fear, surrounded by a sea of Shiites. In most of the remaining Sunni neighborhoods, residents are trapped behind great concrete barricades for their own protection.


That's only a short-term solution. Do you really think this guy is interested in reconciling with the central government?

Naiem al-Qaisi was imprisoned for four months, beaten, shocked with electric probes and, he said, forced to witness fellow Sunni male prisoners being raped by Shiite soldiers of the Iraqi army.

Now he wants to be a policeman. The American military recruited Qaisi and thousands like him to fight the Sunni insurgent group al-Qaeda in Iraq, but Qaisi's most feared enemies are soldiers in the Iraqi army's Muthanna Brigade, and his allegiance does not lie with the government he is now being trained to serve.

"We don't trust this government. This government belongs to Iran," said the 29-year-old former security guard for a soft-drink company. "The Iraqi government knows we are innocent guys, but they want to kill us."


We're setting up the conditions for a massive civil war. And the current metrics show the surge to be a failure.

The U.S. military buildup that was supposed to calm Baghdad and other trouble spots has failed to usher in national reconciliation, as the capital's neighborhoods rupture even further along sectarian lines, violence shifts elsewhere and Iraq's government remains mired in political infighting [...]

Despite the plan, which has brought an additional 28,500 U.S. troops to Iraq since February, none of the major legislation that Washington had expected the Iraqi parliament to pass into law has been approved.

The number of Iraqis fleeing their homes has increased, not decreased, according to the United Nations' International Organization for Migration and Iraq's Ministry for Displacement and Migration.

Military officials say sectarian killings in Baghdad are down more than 51% and attacks on civilians and security forces across Iraq have decreased. But this has not translated into a substantial drop in civilian deaths as insurgents take their lethal trade to more remote regions. Last month, as many as 400 people were killed in a bombing in a village near the Syrian border, the worst bombing since the war began in March 2003. In July, 150 people were reported killed in a village about 100 miles north of Baghdad [...]

"The military offensive has temporarily suppressed, or in many cases dislocated, armed groups," said Joost Hiltermann of the International Crisis Group. "Once the military surge peters out, which it will if there is no progress on the political front, these groups will pop right back up and start going at each other's, and civilians', throats again."


Bush is talking about drawing down troops because he knows he has to in the spring and he's trying to make it seem like it's being done out of strength rather than the weakness of a broken military. He's delaying the inevitable breakup of Iraq that he's facilitating. Anyone duped into thinking that this escalation provided security or progress to Iraq is out of their minds.

Labels: , , , , , , , ,

|

Monday, March 12, 2007

What About The Fingers That Aren't Purple?

Imagine if you held an election in a blue state like, say, Wisconsin, and all the Republicans in the state boycotted the election because they termed it unfair, and so Democrats were elected everywhere, including in Republican-majority areas, and the Democrats then started indiscriminantly persecuting and killing Republicans simply by virtue of their political party. And suppose that if the Republicans complained and asked for new elections to better represent the character of certain areas of the state, the Democrats just said "No." One would think that would be a disastrous circumstance and a sure way to lead to a civil war, wouldn't one?

Welcome to Iraq.

The long delay in holding provincial elections in Iraq has shut out Sunni Arab majorities and exacerbated sectarian tensions in provincial capitals such as Kirkuk and Baqubah and in mixed neighborhoods of Baghdad.

A Sunni boycott of elections in 2005 has left the religious sect underrepresented in some provincial councils and has allowed Shiite politicians to dominate.

The stark political imbalance is a key driver of sectarian violence between Sunni and Shiite Muslims in some of Iraq's most strategically important and heterogeneous cities, Iraqi politicians and U.S. officials say.

Plans to draft legislation to hold new local balloting have been put off indefinitely by the Shiite-dominated parliament, intensifying tensions with Sunni Arabs who have been pushing for new elections.

Sunni Arabs constitute at least 40% of Baghdad's population, but only one of the 51 members of the local provincial council is Sunni.

"The absence of Sunnis on the council has an absolutely negative effect," said Azhar Abdul Majeed Hussein, the sole Sunni council member in Baghdad. "When Sunnis turn to the council for even simple needs, they find they have no representatives. This makes them feel marginalized. There is a clear sectarian spirit in the council."


Some would say that Sunnis are now paying for their lack of participation in provincial elections; in fact, this is the core of the Shiite counter-argument. But does that really matter when this under-representation clearly is worsening the situation in many provinces? This, incidentally, is also contributing to the sustained insurgency; there's always a grievance, always a group of Shiites running the provinces available for directed anger. This is even true in mostly Sunni provinces like al-Anbar and Salahuddin.

If Iraq is supposedly so dedicated to democratic society, they ought to prove it by holding new provincial elections and balancing representation throughout the various sects. Right now there are leaders without any kind of mandate, since so few people voted for them. It's a smaller point set against the wider sectarian rift in Iraq, but it's certainly a contributing factor.

Labels: , , ,

|